There is no universal timeline for engineering journal peer review. A reasonable planning estimate is several weeks for an initial decision and approximately three to six months or longer for the full submission-to-acceptance process, particularly when revisions or additional review rounds are required.
The following ranges are broad planning estimates, not guaranteed industry-wide averages.
| Stage | Illustrative time range |
|---|---|
| Initial editorial screening | A few days to 2–3 weeks |
| Reviewer invitation and assignment | 1–4 weeks or longer |
| First external review round | 3–8 weeks or longer |
| Author revisions | 2–8 weeks, depending on the requested changes and deadline |
| Additional review rounds | Several weeks to a few months |
| Final editorial decision | Days to several weeks after the necessary reviews and revisions |
| Production after acceptance | A few days to several weeks or longer |
Some stages overlap, and others may be repeated. For example, a revised manuscript may return to the original reviewers for another assessment. As a result, these ranges should not be added together to calculate an exact publication date.
A straightforward paper may move through the process more quickly, while a manuscript requiring substantial experiments, additional analysis, or multiple revision rounds may take considerably longer.
What Do Actual Journal Timelines Look Like?
Individual journal metrics illustrate why authors should check the specific publication rather than rely on a general estimate.
For example, MDPI's engineering journal Eng reported a median of approximately 18.8 days from submission to first decision for papers published in the first half of 2026. This is a journal-specific statistic and does not mean every manuscript received a decision in that period.
Elsevier's journal Engineering lists separate metrics for time to first decision, review time, and submission to acceptance. Its displayed figures illustrate that these measures describe different stages of the process.
These examples should not be interpreted as benchmarks for every engineering journal. The subject area, editorial workflow, reviewer availability, and definition of each metric all affect the comparison.
When comparing journals, check the official journal page for:
- Time from submission to first decision
- Time from submission to first decision after external review
- Time from submission to acceptance
- Time from acceptance to online publication
If a journal does not report these metrics, contact the editorial office for clarification when necessary. Authors comparing outlets may also find top engineering journals offering rapid peer review and publication useful.
Understanding the Stages of Engineering Journal Peer Review
Knowing what happens after submission can help authors understand why a manuscript may remain under review for several weeks.
1. Initial editorial screening
After submission, the editorial office checks whether the manuscript meets basic requirements. The editor may assess whether the research fits the journal's scope, whether the files are complete, and whether the paper meets minimum standards for technical quality and originality.
The editor may also check ethical declarations, formatting, references, and potential overlap with previously published work.
If the manuscript is unsuitable, the journal may issue a desk rejection without sending it for external review. If the submission has technical problems, it may be returned for corrections.
This stage can be relatively quick, but incomplete submissions or a large editorial workload may cause delays.
2. Assignment to an editor
A suitable editor or associate editor is assigned to handle the manuscript. The editor considers the research topic and identifies reviewers with relevant expertise.
Engineering papers can involve specialized areas such as structural reliability, semiconductor devices, advanced materials, power electronics, robotics, artificial intelligence, or computational fluid dynamics. Finding reviewers who understand the precise subject can take time.
3. Reviewer invitation and acceptance
The editor invites potential reviewers to evaluate the paper. Some invitees decline because of workload, competing deadlines, conflicts of interest, or limited expertise in the specific topic.
The editor may need to invite several candidates before obtaining the required number of reviewers. This is one reason a manuscript can remain at a status such as "reviewer invited" for an extended period.
4. External peer review
Reviewers assess the research contribution, methodology, validity of the results, quality of the analysis, relevant literature, and clarity of presentation.
Depending on the study, they may examine experimental design, mathematical models, simulation assumptions, benchmark comparisons, uncertainty analysis, or reproducibility.
Reviewers submit comments and recommendations to the editor. The time required depends on the complexity of the paper and the reviewers' availability. Authors preparing manuscripts should ensure their work follows sound engineering research methodology concepts, types, and applications to reduce avoidable review delays.
5. First editorial decision
After considering the reviews, the editor communicates a decision. Common outcomes include:
- Accept: The manuscript is accepted without further substantive changes, although final production checks may remain.
- Minor revision: The authors must address relatively limited concerns.
- Major revision: Substantial changes, additional analysis, or further validation may be required.
- Reject: The journal declines to publish the manuscript.
- Additional review: The editor may seek further opinions before deciding.
A first decision is not necessarily an acceptance. In many cases, it is a request for revision or a rejection.
6. Author revision
If revisions are requested, the authors must address the editor's and reviewers' comments. The time needed depends on the number and complexity of the requested changes.
Correcting a few unclear explanations may take days. Repeating experiments, collecting new data, redesigning a simulation, or performing additional statistical analysis may require weeks or months.
Authors should follow the revision deadline specified by the journal. If the work cannot reasonably be completed by that deadline, request an extension before it expires.
7. Re-review and final decision
For a major revision, the editor may send the revised manuscript back to the original reviewers. They assess whether the authors have adequately addressed the concerns.
A further revision round may follow if important issues remain unresolved. Once the editor has sufficient information to make a decision, the manuscript may be accepted or rejected.
8. Production and publication
Acceptance does not always mean that the final article will appear online immediately. The paper may need copyediting, typesetting, proof correction, metadata preparation, licence completion, and other production checks.
Some journals publish accepted articles online quickly, while others have longer production schedules. Authors should distinguish the time to acceptance from the time to publication.
Why Does Engineering Journal Peer Review Take So Long?
Several factors can affect how quickly an engineering manuscript moves through review.
Limited reviewer availability
Researchers are often invited to review papers alongside their teaching, research, administrative responsibilities, and own publication deadlines. If invited reviewers decline or do not respond, the editor must find alternatives.
Technical complexity of the research
A paper involving sophisticated mathematical analysis, extensive laboratory experiments, complex simulations, or specialized engineering equipment may require reviewers with narrow areas of expertise.
The more specialized the manuscript, the more difficult it may be to identify available experts.
Incomplete or unclear manuscripts
A manuscript with missing methodological details, inconsistent results, poorly labelled figures, or unclear explanations can require additional editorial checks or more extensive reviewer feedback.
A well-prepared paper does not guarantee a faster review, but it can reduce avoidable technical problems. Guidance on how to write a research paper article in engineering can help authors present their work more clearly.
Multiple revision rounds
Some manuscripts require only minor corrections, while others need substantial changes. Each revision round can involve author preparation, editorial assessment, and another period of external review.
This is why submission-to-acceptance timelines are often longer than first-decision timelines.
Journal workload and editorial capacity
The number of submissions, availability of editors, seasonal workload, and efficiency of the editorial system can influence processing times.
Two journals covering similar engineering topics may therefore have very different timelines.
Research ethics or data concerns
Questions about originality, permissions, research ethics, data availability, or conflicting declarations can require additional clarification before a manuscript proceeds.
How Long Does Each Editorial Decision Take?
The time needed to receive a decision depends on the type of outcome and the work required to reach it.
| Decision type | What may affect the timeline |
|---|---|
| Desk rejection | Usually depends on how quickly the editor completes the initial assessment |
| First decision after external review | Depends on reviewer recruitment, report completion, and editorial assessment |
| Minor revision decision | Depends on the author's response and the editor's final checks |
| Major revision decision | Depends on the scale of changes and whether another review round is required |
| Final acceptance | Depends on whether all substantive concerns have been resolved |
| Publication after acceptance | Depends on production, proof correction, licensing, and publication workflow |
An early rejection does not necessarily mean that a journal's peer-review system is faster overall. Similarly, a long review period does not automatically indicate that a journal is more rigorous.
Authors should evaluate review speed alongside journal scope, peer-review quality, editorial transparency, and publication standards. A broader comparison is available in top factors to consider when selecting an engineering journal for publication.
How Can Authors Check a Journal's Review Timeline Before Submission?
Checking the journal's own metrics is more useful than relying on general claims about engineering publication speed.
Visit the official journal website
Look for a section titled "Journal Metrics," "Journal Insights," "Review Process," or "Information for Authors." Some publishers report median or average processing times.
For instance, Elsevier explains that authors can use the Journal Insights section on participating journal pages to review the time taken to reach first and final decisions. The publisher also advises authors to contact the editor if their manuscript has been waiting considerably longer than the journal's reported review speed.
Understand what each metric means
A journal may report the time from submission to first decision, which can include manuscripts rejected before external review. A separate post-review metric may better reflect the wait for papers that actually enter peer review.
Always read the metric definition before comparing journals.
Check the reporting period
A figure based on recent submissions may differ from a historical average. Verify whether the metric covers the last six months, the previous calendar year, or a longer period.
Ask the editorial office when appropriate
If the journal does not publish review statistics, you can ask about its typical first-decision and review timelines. Treat any estimate as guidance rather than a guarantee.
What Should You Do If Your Engineering Paper Is Taking Too Long?
Waiting can be frustrating, particularly when a paper is needed for a thesis, academic evaluation, grant requirement, or professional milestone. However, a delay does not necessarily indicate a problem with the manuscript.
Check the manuscript status
Log in to the submission portal and review the current status. Common labels include:
- Submitted: The system has received the manuscript
- Technical check: Staff are checking files and submission requirements
- With editor: An editor is assessing or managing the paper
- Reviewer invited: The editor is inviting potential reviewers
- Under review: The manuscript is in the review process, although the exact meaning varies by journal
- Required reviews completed: The expected reports may have arrived, but the editor may still need to evaluate them
- Decision in process: An editorial decision is being prepared
Status labels vary across editorial systems, so consult the journal's own guidance rather than assuming that a particular status always means the same thing.
Compare the elapsed time with the journal's metrics
If the manuscript has been under review for three weeks and the journal typically reports a first post-review decision after several weeks, additional waiting may be normal.
If the manuscript has remained at the same stage substantially longer than the journal's reported timeline, a polite inquiry may be appropriate.
Send a professional status inquiry
The corresponding author should contact the editorial office through the journal's designated channel. Include the manuscript ID, title, submission date, and current status.
Keep the message brief and courteous. Ask whether any information is needed from the authors and whether an updated timeline is available.
Avoid repeated messages over short intervals unless the journal requests further communication.
Avoid submitting the same paper elsewhere simultaneously
A delayed decision is not permission to submit the manuscript to another journal while it remains under consideration. If you decide to withdraw the paper, follow the journal's formal withdrawal procedure and obtain confirmation before submitting elsewhere. Understanding why IJOER is not a predatory journal can help authors recognize legitimate editorial practices.
How to Reduce Avoidable Delays in Engineering Journal Submission
Authors cannot control reviewer availability or editorial workload, but they can improve the quality and completeness of the submission.
Select the right journal
Read the aims and scope, examine recent publications, and ensure that the manuscript's subject and contribution match the journal. An unsuitable submission may be rejected before external review.
Follow the author guidelines
Check the manuscript format, figure requirements, reference style, word limits, supplementary files, and required declarations before submission.
Present methods clearly
Describe experimental procedures, equipment, models, assumptions, parameters, and evaluation methods in enough detail for reviewers to assess the reliability of the work.
Verify figures, tables, and results
Ensure that labels are readable, units are consistent, and results match across the text, figures, and tables. Explain the significance of the findings rather than simply reporting numerical outcomes.
Respond to reviewers systematically
When revisions are requested, prepare a point-by-point response. Address each comment, explain the changes made, and provide a reasoned response when a suggested change cannot be adopted.
Identify revised sections or line numbers according to the journal's instructions. A clear response helps the editor assess how the concerns have been resolved.
Does a Faster Peer-Review Process Mean a Better Journal?
Not necessarily. Review speed is only one aspect of a journal's publishing process.
A short first-decision time may reflect efficient editorial screening, but it may also include desk rejections. A longer timeline may result from reviewer shortages, multiple revision rounds, or the technical complexity of the research.
Authors should also assess:
- Whether the journal's scope fits the manuscript
- Whether the peer-review process is transparent
- Whether editors and reviewers have relevant expertise
- Whether publication ethics policies are clear
- Whether indexing claims are independently verifiable
- Whether fees and open access terms are transparent
- Whether the journal publishes work of an appropriate academic standard
Be cautious of journals that guarantee acceptance or promise unrealistically short review periods regardless of manuscript quality. Independently verifying indexing claims, such as through what Scopus indexing is and its importance in engineering research, is part of that assessment.
Continue Exploring
Engineering journal peer review can take several weeks to several months, and the complete submission-to-acceptance process may take longer when substantial revisions or multiple review rounds are needed. The most reliable estimate comes from the target journal's own processing-time statistics and editorial policies.
Before submitting, check the journal's scope, recent review metrics, formatting instructions, and publication requirements. After submission, monitor the status, respond promptly to editorial requests, and send a courteous inquiry if the manuscript has exceeded the expected timeline substantially. A realistic understanding of the process helps researchers plan their publication schedules without confusing the first decision, final acceptance, and online publication.

