1. Manuscript Submission Confirmation

The process begins when an author submits the manuscript through the journal's online submission system. Some journals may also accept submissions through other approved methods, but online manuscript management systems are common.

During submission, authors generally provide:

  • The manuscript file
  • The title and abstract
  • Keywords and subject classifications
  • Author names, affiliations, and contact details
  • The corresponding author's information
  • Figures, tables, supplementary files, and other required documents
  • A cover letter, where required
  • Conflict-of-interest and funding declarations
  • Ethical approval statements or other declarations, where applicable

Authors may also need to confirm that the manuscript is original, has not been published previously in a way that violates the journal's policy, and is not simultaneously under consideration by another journal.

After completing the submission process, the system usually generates a confirmation message or email. The manuscript may receive a submission identification number, which should be saved for future correspondence.

What should authors do?

Check the confirmation email carefully. If no confirmation arrives, review the submission dashboard and spam folder before contacting the journal. Authors should also ensure that the uploaded manuscript is the correct version and that all required files have been included.

2. Initial Editorial Screening

After submission, the manuscript normally enters an initial screening stage. Depending on the journal, this may be conducted by an editorial office member, an editor, or both.

The purpose is to determine whether the submission meets the journal's basic requirements and is suitable for further consideration.

What does the journal check?

The editorial screening process may include:

  • Scope suitability: Does the research fit the journal's engineering discipline and stated aims?
  • Completeness: Are the required files, declarations, figures, and supplementary materials included?
  • Formatting: Does the manuscript follow the journal's author guidelines?
  • Language and presentation: Is the paper sufficiently clear for editorial assessment?
  • Research contribution: Does the work appear to offer a meaningful technical contribution?
  • Ethical compliance: Are relevant approvals, consent statements, and declarations provided?
  • Originality concerns: Are there indications of plagiarism, inappropriate text reuse, or other publication-integrity issues?
  • Policy compliance: Does the manuscript meet the journal's requirements for authorship, data availability, and related disclosures?

The depth of this screening varies. Some journals perform detailed technical checks, while others conduct a relatively brief initial assessment.

What happens if the manuscript does not pass screening?

The journal may return the submission for technical corrections, request missing documents, or reject the manuscript without external peer review. A rejection at this stage is often called a desk rejection.

A desk rejection does not necessarily mean that the research has no value. The paper may be outside the journal's scope, insufficiently developed for its readership, or unsuitable for the journal's editorial priorities.

What should authors do?

Read the journal's aims and scope before submission. Check its formatting instructions, required declarations, article types, and reference style. Reviewing top factors to consider when selecting an engineering journal for publication can help authors avoid avoidable desk rejections. If the manuscript is rejected, review the editor's explanation before deciding whether to revise it for another journal.

3. Assignment to an Editor

If the manuscript passes the initial checks, it is usually assigned to an editor. Depending on the journal's structure, this may be an editor-in-chief, associate editor, section editor, or handling editor.

The editor evaluates the manuscript's relevance, potential contribution, technical focus, and suitability for peer review. The editor may also consider whether appropriate reviewers are available.

For engineering research, the editor may examine whether the paper presents a clear technical problem, uses appropriate methods, provides adequate experimental or analytical evidence, and explains how the findings contribute to existing knowledge.

For example, a manuscript on a new structural health monitoring algorithm may need to demonstrate how the proposed approach compares with established methods. A paper on renewable energy systems may need to explain the experimental setup, assumptions, performance metrics, and limitations of the proposed system.

The editor may decide to:

  • Send the manuscript for external peer review
  • Request preliminary clarification or technical corrections
  • Reject the manuscript without external review

Important: Being assigned to an editor does not mean that the paper has been accepted for peer review, and it certainly does not guarantee publication.

4. Reviewer Selection and Invitation

If the editor decides that external assessment is appropriate, the next step is identifying suitable peer reviewers.

Reviewers are generally selected according to their expertise in the manuscript's subject area, research methods, or technical application. For interdisciplinary engineering papers, the editor may need reviewers with different specializations.

For example, a paper combining machine learning and civil engineering might require reviewers familiar with both computational methods and structural applications.

The editor invites potential reviewers, who can accept or decline the invitation. Some may be unavailable, have a conflict of interest, or feel that the topic falls outside their expertise. The editor may therefore need to invite several candidates before obtaining enough reviews.

This stage can take time, particularly when the subject is highly specialized or reviewers have significant academic and professional commitments.

What is the author's role at this stage?

Usually, the author does not need to take any action. The corresponding author can monitor the manuscript's status through the submission system.

If the status remains unchanged for an extended period, a polite inquiry may be appropriate. However, a status label alone does not always reveal whether the editor is finding reviewers, waiting for reports, or completing another internal task.

Engineering Journal IJOER Call for Papers

5. External Peer Review

Peer review is one of the most important stages in engineering journal publication. Selected experts evaluate the manuscript and provide feedback to the editor.

The review model depends on the journal. Common approaches include single-anonymized review, double-anonymized review, and open peer review. Authors should consult the journal's policy to understand whether reviewer identities or author identities are disclosed.

What do reviewers evaluate?

Although the criteria differ across engineering disciplines, reviewers commonly assess the following areas.

Originality and contribution

Does the manuscript provide a meaningful contribution beyond existing research? Is the research question important and clearly defined?

Technical soundness

Are the equations, models, algorithms, simulations, experiments, and analytical methods appropriate? Are the assumptions justified?

Methodology and reproducibility

Does the paper provide enough methodological detail for readers to understand and, where possible, reproduce the work? Are datasets, code, equipment specifications, and experimental conditions described adequately? Authors can strengthen this aspect by following sound engineering research methodology concepts, types, and applications.

Results and interpretation

Are the results presented clearly? Do the conclusions follow from the evidence? Are comparisons with relevant existing methods included where appropriate?

Literature review

Does the manuscript engage with relevant and current research? Are important studies missing, and are citations used accurately?

Figures, tables, and technical writing

Are diagrams, plots, tables, units, symbols, and terminology clear and consistent? Does the paper explain its findings without unnecessary repetition?

Limitations and practical significance

Does the manuscript acknowledge limitations? Are claims about performance, reliability, efficiency, cost, or practical applications supported by evidence?

Reviewers typically submit reports containing comments and recommendations. Their recommendations may include acceptance, minor revision, major revision, or rejection. The editor makes the formal decision, taking the reports and journal policies into account.

6. Editorial Decision After Peer Review

Once the editor has received sufficient reviewer feedback, the manuscript moves to an editorial decision.

The wording and categories differ between journals, but decisions commonly fall into the following groups.

Accept

The editor accepts the manuscript for publication. Acceptance may be followed by copyediting, typesetting, author proof review, and other production steps.

Acceptance without further changes is possible but not guaranteed, even when reviewers are generally positive.

Minor revision

The paper is considered promising, but the authors must address relatively limited concerns. These might involve clarifying a method, improving a figure, correcting references, explaining a limitation, or responding to a specific technical question.

Minor revision does not automatically guarantee acceptance. The editor must still be satisfied that the requested changes have been addressed.

Major revision

The paper may have potential, but substantial changes are required before the editor can make a final decision. Reviewers may request additional analyses, clearer methodological explanations, stronger comparisons, improved validation, or a more careful interpretation of results.

Major revision can require significant work, particularly when the comments concern experimental design, model validation, statistical analysis, or the strength of the paper's conclusions.

Reject

The editor may reject the manuscript because of insufficient novelty, methodological weaknesses, limited relevance to the journal, unsupported conclusions, or other concerns.

Sometimes a journal offers an opportunity to submit a substantially revised manuscript as a new submission. Authors should not assume that this option is available unless it is explicitly stated in the decision letter.

Reject and transfer

Some publishers offer a manuscript-transfer option when another journal within their portfolio may be a better fit. Transfer procedures and editorial requirements vary, and a transfer does not itself guarantee acceptance.

7. Revising the Manuscript After Reviewer Feedback

If the decision is minor or major revision, authors should read the editor's letter and all reviewer comments carefully before changing the manuscript.

A strong revision addresses the substance of each concern rather than merely editing the wording.

Step 1: Organize the reviewer comments

Separate comments into categories such as methodology, experimental validation, literature review, figures, writing, and references. This makes it easier to plan the work and identify related requests.

Step 2: Prepare a point-by-point response

Authors usually submit a response letter that reproduces or summarizes each reviewer comment and explains the action taken.

A useful response includes:

  • The reviewer's comment
  • The author's response
  • The changes made to the manuscript
  • The relevant page, section, figure, table, or line number, where available

For example:

Reviewer comment: The proposed algorithm is not adequately compared with existing approaches.

Author response: Thank you for highlighting this concern. We have added a comparison with two relevant baseline methods using the same evaluation dataset and performance metrics. The new results are presented in Section 4.3 and discussed in Table 5.

This type of response is specific and allows the editor to verify the revision.

Step 3: Make the changes easy to identify

Depending on the journal's instructions, authors may provide a marked-up manuscript, a clean revised manuscript, or both. Use the requested file format and highlighting method.

Step 4: Explain when a suggestion cannot be followed

Authors do not have to agree automatically with every reviewer suggestion. If a requested experiment is impractical or a comment is based on a misunderstanding, explain the reasoning respectfully and provide evidence where possible.

If additional analysis is necessary to support a claim, however, a brief disagreement may not be sufficient.

Step 5: Check the revised submission

Before resubmitting, confirm that every comment has been addressed, all files are included, references are accurate, and the response letter matches the changes in the manuscript.

8. Resubmission and Further Review

After revising the paper, authors upload the revised files and response letter through the journal's submission system.

The editor then assesses whether the changes address the concerns raised during the previous round. Depending on the journal and the nature of the revisions, the editor may make a decision directly or send the manuscript back to some or all of the original reviewers.

A second review round may result in:

  • Acceptance
  • Another minor or major revision
  • Rejection

Some manuscripts require multiple rounds of revision, while others are accepted after one round. The number of rounds depends on the manuscript, the reviewers' concerns, and the journal's editorial process.

Authors should follow the revision deadline stated in the decision letter. If more time is needed, they should contact the editorial office before the deadline and explain the reason. An extension is not automatic.

9. Final Acceptance and Publication Preparation

Once the editor is satisfied with the manuscript, the journal issues an acceptance decision. The paper then enters the production stage.

Acceptance and publication are separate milestones. An accepted manuscript may still need several production checks before the final version becomes available.

Copyediting and language checks

The publisher may review grammar, spelling, terminology, reference formatting, and consistency. Technical meaning should be preserved, especially in equations, units, symbols, and engineering terminology.

Typesetting and layout

The manuscript is formatted according to the journal's publication style. Figures, tables, equations, headings, affiliations, and references are arranged for publication.

Author proofs

The corresponding author may receive page proofs or an online proofing link. Authors should check:

  • Names and affiliations
  • Equations, symbols, and units
  • Figure and table placement
  • Captions and cross-references
  • References and hyperlinks
  • Formatting errors introduced during production
  • Any factual or typographical errors

Proof correction is generally not intended for extensive rewriting or the introduction of major new results. The journal's proof instructions should be followed carefully.

Publication agreements and charges

Depending on the journal and publication model, authors may need to complete a copyright agreement or open-access licence. Publication charges may apply, but not every journal charges an article processing charge. Authors should rely on the journal's official fee policy and any applicable institutional or funder agreement. For a broader view of what fees can apply, see top DOAJ open access journals in engineering.

Online publication

The article may first appear online as an early version of record or under another publication format used by the journal. It may later be assigned to a specific issue, volume, or page range. The exact sequence depends on the publisher.

Once published, the paper generally receives a persistent identifier, such as a DOI, if the journal's publication process provides one. Authors should verify the published article's metadata and share the official publication link.

10. How Long Does the Engineering Journal Publication Process Take?

There is no universal timeline for engineering journal publication. The duration depends on the journal, discipline, reviewer availability, editorial workload, number of revision rounds, and production process.

The following table illustrates the stages without promising a fixed duration.

Stage What happens What may affect timing
Submission confirmation The system records the manuscript Technical problems or incomplete submission
Initial screening Editorial and compliance checks Missing files, formatting, policy checks
Editor assignment An editor assesses suitability Editorial workload and scope
Reviewer selection Experts are invited Availability and subject specialization
Peer review Reviewers assess the manuscript Complexity and review response times
Revision Authors address comments Amount of additional analysis required
Final decision Editor evaluates the revised paper Reviewer feedback and editorial judgment
Production Proofs, formatting, and publication preparation Publisher workflow and author corrections

Some journals publish average times for initial decisions, peer review, or acceptance-to-publication. These measures describe different stages and should not be treated as interchangeable.

For example, a journal's time to first decision may include desk rejections and may not represent the time required for a paper that undergoes full peer review. Similarly, the time from acceptance to online publication excludes the earlier review process.

Best practice: Check the journal's official journal metrics or author information, if available. Treat any published average as an estimate rather than a guarantee. A closer comparison of review speeds is available in top engineering journals offering rapid peer review and publication.

11. Understanding Common Manuscript Statuses

The status labels displayed in a submission portal vary between publishers. The same label may also have slightly different meanings across systems.

Status label Common meaning
Submitted The manuscript has been received by the system
Technical check Files and submission requirements are being checked
With editor An editor is assessing or managing the manuscript
Editor assigned A handling editor has been assigned
Reviewer invited Potential reviewers have been contacted
Under review The manuscript is undergoing review or is in a review-related workflow
Required reviews completed The expected review reports may have been received; editorial assessment may still be pending
Decision in process An editorial decision is being prepared
Revision required The journal has requested changes
Accepted The manuscript has received an acceptance decision
In production The publisher is preparing the article for publication

These labels are not standardized across all journals. For example, "under review" may refer to different internal steps, and the status does not necessarily reveal how many reviewers have responded.

Authors should avoid interpreting every status change as a positive or negative signal. When the status is unclear, the journal's help documentation or editorial office is the best source of clarification.

12. What Should Authors Do While Waiting for a Decision?

Waiting for an editorial decision can be challenging, especially for students and researchers working toward academic milestones. However, there are several productive steps authors can take.

Keep the submission records

Save the manuscript ID, submission confirmation, submitted files, cover letter, and any correspondence with the journal.

Monitor official communication

Check the submission dashboard and email regularly. Respond promptly to requests for missing documents or clarification.

Avoid duplicate submissions

Unless the journal has formally withdrawn or rejected the manuscript, do not submit the same paper to another journal simultaneously when the journals' policies prohibit concurrent consideration. Understanding why IJOER is not a predatory journal can help authors recognize journals that follow transparent editorial practices.

Continue related research

Use the waiting period to develop related experiments, improve a dataset, read new literature, or prepare another independent research project. Do not submit substantially overlapping work without considering publication ethics and disclosure requirements.

Follow up professionally

If the manuscript has been pending well beyond the journal's stated timeline, a brief, polite inquiry to the editorial office may be appropriate. Include the manuscript ID, title, submission date, and current portal status.

Avoid sending repeated messages at short intervals. A status delay alone does not establish that the journal has lost the manuscript or that the paper will be rejected.

13. What If the Engineering Journal Rejects the Paper?

Rejection is part of scholarly publishing and can happen at different stages. The most useful next step is to understand the reasons provided by the editor.

Authors can group the feedback into several categories:

  • Scope mismatch: The research may be suitable for another engineering journal
  • Limited novelty: The contribution may not be sufficiently differentiated from previous studies
  • Methodological concerns: The experimental design, model, assumptions, or analysis may need improvement
  • Insufficient validation: The results may not support the paper's claims
  • Presentation problems: The research may be difficult to evaluate because of unclear writing, figures, or structure
  • Research-integrity concerns: Questions about originality, authorship, data, or ethical compliance may need careful resolution

Before submitting elsewhere, revise the paper where appropriate. Confirm that the next journal accepts the article type, covers the research topic, and has publication policies that fit the author's needs.

If the rejection letter identifies a serious technical weakness, changing journals without addressing that weakness may lead to the same outcome. If the main issue is journal scope, selecting a better-matched publication may be the more appropriate solution.

14. How to Improve the Chances of a Smooth Publication Process

Authors cannot control reviewer availability or guarantee acceptance, but they can reduce avoidable problems.

Choose a suitable journal. Compare the journal's aims, scope, article types, recent publications, and author instructions with the manuscript.

Follow the submission checklist. Check formatting, figure quality, references, supplementary files, and required declarations before uploading.

Present a clear contribution. State the engineering problem, research gap, proposed approach, and main contribution explicitly. Guidance on how to write a research paper article in engineering can help authors frame their contribution clearly.

Use rigorous methods. Explain the experimental setup, data sources, assumptions, evaluation metrics, and limitations in sufficient detail.

Make claims proportional to evidence. Avoid overstating performance, novelty, generalizability, or real-world applicability.

Respond professionally to reviewers. Address each comment carefully and support disagreements with reasoned explanations.

Verify journal legitimacy. Check the journal's publisher, editorial board, peer-review policy, fees, publication history, and claims about indexing through authoritative sources. Do not rely solely on promotional emails or unverified indexing badges. A useful reference on legitimate database coverage is what Scopus indexing is and its importance in engineering research.

For engineering researchers considering journals such as the International Journal of Engineering Research and Science (IJOER), the same due-diligence principles apply: verify the journal's current scope, submission requirements, fees, editorial policies, and indexing claims before submitting.

Continue Exploring

After a research paper is submitted to an engineering journal, it usually moves through administrative checks, editorial screening, reviewer selection, peer review, an editorial decision, and—if accepted—publication preparation. Some manuscripts are rejected early, while others require one or more rounds of revision before a final decision.

Authors can navigate the process more confidently by understanding the stages, following journal instructions, keeping accurate submission records, and responding constructively to editorial feedback. A successful submission is not simply about uploading a manuscript; it is about presenting technically sound research to an appropriate journal and engaging professionally with the publication process.